A university removed the data of a former student contained in an electoral roll from its website, but had not responded to his request for deletion. It had also left two subsequent invitations from the Authority unanswered, communicating the removal only after the start of the sanctioning procedure. The Authority ascertained the violation of art. 5, 12 and 17 GDPR and imposed a fine of 4,000 euros on the University.
The decision highlights two distinct obligations. The controller must assess and, when the conditions are met, execute the request for erasure; it must also notify the data subject of what it has done, without undue delay and in any case within one month of receiving the request. If it cannot accept it, it must explain the reason and indicate the possibility of contacting the Data Protection Authority or the judge. In the cases provided for by the GDPR, the deadline can be extended, but the data subject must be informed within the first month. The subsequent removal of the data does not eliminate the violation already accrued due to the lack of response.
For companies and PAs, the case suggests treating each privacy request as a traceable procedure: recording the date of receipt, assigning a person responsible for the response, verifying the outcome of the technical intervention and keeping evidence of both the action taken and the communication sent to the data subject. It is also necessary to monitor the Authority's requests separately: in the case examined, the lack of cooperation was considered by the Authority in determining the sanction.