A person lodges a complaint with the data protection authority and then asks to know his or her personal data contained in the relevant file. Can the authority reject the request by invoking a rule that excludes access to his files en bloc? In Bayerisches Landesamt für Datenschutzaufsicht (C-205/25), the Court of Justice answered no. When processing the data collected and produced in the context of the complaint, the supervisory authority is itself the data controller: the complainant can therefore exercise the right of access under Article 15 GDPR against him, in principle.
However, the ruling makes a precise distinction between access to personal data and indistinct access to the entire administrative file. The former is protected by the GDPR; the latter does not automatically follow from Article 15. The authority must assess what information actually concerns the applicant and balance the request with the rights and freedoms of other persons. Where possible, the redaction or anonymisation of third-party data makes it possible to provide the necessary information without disclosing the information to be protected. Article 23 GDPR allows legislative limitations on the right of access only within its strict conditions: it does not justify a generalised exclusion of all personal data in the authority's files.
On an operational level, the ruling is primarily of interest to the supervisory authorities, which must be able to examine these requests individually and justify any limitations. It is also relevant for the companies involved in the investigation: documents, replies and attachments sent to the authority may contain data of the complainant together with third-party or confidential information. It is advisable to identify them accurately from the moment they are transmitted, so that the protection needs can be assessed concretely, without presuming that the placement in the file makes everything automatically ostensible or, on the contrary, everything secret.